Is Your Safety Record Costing You? Understanding Your Experience Mod

Is Your Safety Record Costing You? Understanding Your Experience Mod

| January 21, 2026

For many employers, Workers’ Compensation insurance comes down to a single number: the premium. Some might think this is uncontrollable, but the reality is that business owners have more control than they think. For Workers' Comp insurance, the premium is calculated using a rating of your company's loss history known as the Experience Modification Factor (or Experience Mod). The good news? This rating fluctuates with your safety record, meaning a safer workplace can directly lead to lower insurance premiums.

Experience Mod Explained

Think of your Experience Mod as a "safety credit score" for your business. It compares your company's claims history to the average for businesses of a similar size in your industry. This is a case where the lower your score, the better. Here’s the breakdown:

  • 1.0 = Average.You pay the standard premium.
  • More than 1.0 = Above Average Losses.You pay a surcharge.
  • Less than 1.0 = Below Average Losses.You earn a discount.

The calculation is based on a three-year rolling average and prioritizes claim frequency over severity, as frequent incidents often point to underlying safety gaps.

Why a Good Score is Great for Business

  • Lower Premiums = More Money for Other Things:A lower Mod can free up funds to invest back into your business: your people, equipment, and future growth.
  • More Business:A low Experience Mod is often a requirement to qualify for contracts. It signals your reliability to potential clients.
  • You'll Attract More Candidates:A low Mod says something about your company culture. It demonstrates a commitment to employee safety.

Four Ways to Start Improving Your Score Today

  1. Get a Safety Program Together:We're not talking about a binder on a shelf — we're talking about creating a safety culture from the top down. What you need to do:

  • Commit to Ongoing Training: Move beyond a check-the-box onboarding. Conduct frequent training focused on the real issues your employees might face.
  • Set the Tone with Leadership:Employees take their cues from management. If they moequent training focused on the real issues your employees might face.
  • Encourage Proactive Reporting:Make it safe and simple for employees to report potential hazards without fear of negative consequences. Every report is a learning opportunity and may prevent future incidents.

2. Manage Claims Immediately

  • Report every claim to your insurance carrier the moment it happens.Delays can dramatically increase the cost of a claim, which directly impacts your Mod. Prompt reporting shows you're a responsible partner in risk management.
  • Stay Involved:Don't just "report and forget." Maintain communication with the injured employee and the insurance adjuster. Active management helps resolve claims faster and more efficiently.

3. Implement a Return-to-Work Program

One of the biggest cost drivers in a Workers' Comp claim is lost time from work. A Return-to-Work program is an effective tool to combat this. By offering light or modified-duty assignments, you can bring injured employees back into the workforce sooner. By implementing a Return-to-Work program, you will:

  • Reduce claim costs by limiting wage replacement benefits.
  • Keep employees engaged as they recover from injuries.
  • Send a powerful message to your insurance carrier that you are actively managing your claims and risk.

4. Keep Things Clean

Your physical workspace has a direct impact on your Mod. A clean, well-maintained environment naturally prevents common accidents like slips, trips and falls. Tips include:

  • Walk the floor regularly to spot and correct hazards like cluttered walkways, poor lighting, or unmarked spills.
  • Ensure all tools and machinery are in good working order and that employees are trained to use them correctly.
  • Use clear, visible signs for potential hazards, safety procedures, and emergency exits.

Kathleen Hughes is a Risk Communications Strategist at DiNicola Insurance Services. Kathleen is licensed in Property & Casualty, Life, and Accident & Health insurance and holds the Certified Restaurant Risk Professional (CRRP) and Certified Workers' Compensation Specialist (CWCS) designations.